Friday, June 5, 2015

Light therapy for sports injuries: a case study in dubious modalities


In my upcoming book on preventing and managing running injuries (which, I'm sorry to say, is still very much a work in progress), one chapter discusses the roles various medical professionals can fulfill in the prevention, evaluation, and treatment of running injuries.  In many cases, a particular discipline is best-suited for one particular role: a podiatrist is ideally qualified to make custom orthotics, an orthopedist is best-suited to order and evaluate an MRI, and a physical therapist is the right person to create a rehab exercise routine. 

This does not mean that medical specialists see their own role with this narrow view.  There are plenty of physical therapists who prescribe orthotics, chiropractors who order and evaluate MRIs, and so on.  Perhaps because of pride or just a desire to manage all aspects of a patient's treatment, specialists sometimes have a tendency to stray outside of the boundaries of what they do best. 

In my view at least, the primary use of a physical therapist for an injured runner is as a resource for discovering muscular tightness or weakness that contributes to injury, evaluating running gait to identify any biomechanical flaws, and developing a rehab program to return to healthy running.  There are many fantastic physical therapists who focus almost entirely on these aspects of injury treatment. 

But many other physical therapists are wedded to their "modalities"—in-office treatments that purportedly improve healing or reduce pain.  The ones you are probably most familiar with are therapeutic ultrasound and electrostimulation (also known as TENS), but there is a veritable cornucopia of modalities that are sold to physical therapy clinics which claim to reduce pain, speed healing, or otherwise assist with the rehab process.  Some modalities even have research supporting their use, though this almost inevitably consists small, uncontrolled trials. 

Today I want to break up the allure of technological modalities by looking at one specific example called "light therapy."  Though it might sound like a quasi-mystical alternative treatment, light therapy is a real modality used in many physical therapy clinics.  The claim is that an intense beam of light, usually generated by light-emitting diodes (LEDs) or sometimes lasers, can penetrate the skin and stimulate mitochondria in the muscle cells if the light is of the correct wavelength.  The stimulation of the mitochondria allegedly speeds healing from fatigue and injury.  Again, this sounds borderline crackpot-physiology, but that idea is from a real study published in a scientific journal.  

To show that the light therapy machines used in a typical PT clinic are most likely useless and overpriced, I don't have prove that specific wavelengths of light have no effect on muscular mitochondria.  I just need to prove it is no better than any other basic source of light. Like, say, the Sun.
 

The sun is a really fantastic source of light.  As an exceptionally large black-body radiator, it puts out a wide spectrum of very intense light.  Part of this spectrum is in the "therapeutic photon" range of 600 to 1000 nm cited in marketing literature for light therapy devices.

Now, how does the photon output of the sun compare to a typical light therapy machine? We'll take a look a typical machine from Dynatronics, a company which produces equipment for physical therapy offices.  I don't mean to pick on one particular brand—light therapy equipment by Dynatronics is largely identical to products from other companies when it comes to technical specifications—we just need one specific machine to draw technical details from.


The therapeutic photon output of a light therapy machine probe

The Dynatron Solaris 701 is just such a machine.  The unit itself is sold for somewhere in the vicinity of three thousand dollars, and provides light therapy (or ultrasound) through either a 5-five square centimeter light probe ($2,000) or a 8" by 10" light pad ($2,500). 

Let's get right down to technical details.  First, the light probe—the D880 probe has an area of 5 cm2 and emits light through three 660 nanometer (nm) red LEDs and thirty-two 880 nm infrared LEDs. The total power output of the probe is 500 milliwatts (mW), and a typical treatment lasts sixty seconds, which delivers a dose of six joules (J) of energy per square centimeter. 

The power output of the probe looks something like this:

Though the exact height of each peak will depend on the power of the LEDs.

The therapeutic photon power output of the sun

To figure out how sunlight compares to a light therapy machine, we need data on the solar spectrum here on earth.  Fortunately, the solar industry has adopted a standard based on observational data. It's called AM 1.5 or Air Mass 1.5, the number denoting the equivalent atmosphere thickness for a typical location on Earth (like North America).  AM 1.5 is a full spectrum with nanometer-precise information on solar irradiance. 


All we need to do to calculate the solar output in the photon wavelength ranges we're interested in is integrate the AM 1.5 solar spectrum over those wavelengths.  I bet you thought you'd left calculus behind in college—sorry! Integrating this is trivial to do in MS Excel since the AM 1.5 data is provided in units of Watts per meter squared per nanometer—simply summing the power of each .

If I wanted to "cheat" a little bit, I could just integrate the AM 1.5 distribution over the entire therapeutic photon range of 600-1000 nm.  This way I maximize the amount of solar energy I'm allowed to integrate.  By doing it this way, we get a solar power value of 40.4 mW/cm2.  Multiply this by five (because the probe is five square centimeters) and we get a power output of 202 mW.  Not bad compared to the Solaris probe's 500 mW! To get the same six Joule dose, we'd need two and a half minutes of sun exposure versus one minute of probe use. 

But, like I said, that's kind of cheating, because the probe doesn't use a more or less constant power output between 600 and 1000 nanometers; it has two "peaks" from LEDs centered at 660 and 880 nm.  Based on a quick look at some spectral data from an ~820 nm LED (below), we can see the actual wavelength distribution of an infrared LED can be 50 nanometers or more from the peak wavelength. 


Instead, we can just integrate the AM 1.5 from 610 to 710 (660 ± 50) nm and again from 830 to 930 (880 ± 50) nm.  In this case, we get a solar power of 22.6 mW per cm2. Multiply by five again and we get 113 mW.  Still the same order of magnitude! This time, we have to sit in the sun for four and a half minutes instead of one, but hey, we're still saving big bucks because sunlight is completely free.

Dynatronics also offers a large pad of infrared LEDs to cover a larger area with infrared light.  Does this fare any better? According to the technical specifications, the 8" by 10" pad uses two hundred 880 nm LEDs to generate 7500 mW of power.  Unfortunately, this is only 15 mW per square centimeter, as compared to the 100 mW per square centimeter of the probe.  The sun, even measuring only 50 nanometers on either side of 880 nm, is still half as powerful—and is still free.  Because the treatment time for the infrared pad is nine minutes (to achieve a dose of eight joules), your sun time would be twice that, but remember, this is neglecting all of the rest of the "therapeutic photon" spectrum. 

Dynatronics also offers a probe that combines infrared (880 nm) and blue/near-ultraviolet (405 nm) light in a probe with a total power output of 500 mW.  The technical data does not describe how much power is coming from the blue LEDs, but the solar spectrum radiates 65 mW per cm2 between 355 and 455 nm, so even if 90% of the ultraviolet probe's energy was at the 405 nm wavelength, you'd still only need to be in the sun for seven minutes to get the equivalent dose to one minute of blue/infrared light therapy. 

Conclusion

Given the low overall power output of light therapy devices, the only plausible benefits would be from specific cellular interactions with photons, not the general heating effect of absorbing photon energy.  If your goal is to transfer six or eight joules of energy to an injured area, there's a much cheaper and more effective way to do than—it's called a hot pack.

If, instead, we return to the cellular benefit argument, it's very hard to make the case that a light therapy machine would have any meaningful effect.  How could delivering a six joule dose of energy over one minute do any good when you'd get a far greater dose of the same wavelengths of light when you take your dog for a walk around the block on a sunny day?

The great thing about this kind of analysis is that it really does not matter whether or not light therapy "works" or not—if it does, you can get the same exact benefit by laying in the sun for a few minutes.  That will cost you exactly nothing.  There's another whole discussion to be had about why physical therapy offices are purchasing, using, and billing you for a practically useless modality, and yet another discussion to be had about all the peer-reviewed science that supports a treatment method that, on paper, looks completely implausible.  But alas, the lack of rigor in sports injury research papers and the marketing practices of medical equipment manufacturers is a topic for another day.

When in doubt, medical professionals of all stripes need to stick to what they're good at.  For physical therapists, this means the bread and butter of PT school: anatomy, biomechanics, and identifying muscular weakness and tightness.  Fancy machines with sleek marketing info can make all sorts of lofty claims, but unless they are backed by solid scientific evidence and have a mode of action that is at least plausible, you should be very, very skeptical.

60 comments:

  1. What a great day! I am so happy to be incorporating in some training even if it's modified! I am feeling hopeful for Ironman Texas!!This is a good practice

    ReplyDelete
  2. Darts had traditionally been made of brass. Decades later, darts with barrels manufactured from tungsten along with other alloys came into the arena Outdoor Dart Board

    ReplyDelete
  3. There's a lot of talk among both people in the healthcare fields and people who've used inversion therapy. Inversion tables do they work? There are both advantages and disadvantages that you should be aware of.inversion table exercises for neck

    ReplyDelete
  4. Physiologically, the improvement around there in young people is extremely shifted. outdoor activities blog post

    ReplyDelete
  5. it would have been tougher for you too to get up at 5.30am for the walk. So, I take the breaks on the weekends. But on the other days, physically demanding sports

    ReplyDelete
  6. So when someone talks about free sports betting,visit the website you'll probably wonder what they're talking about.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I love watching Furman football. This season has been pretty terrible in the NFL so I'm all about watching college ball instead. I'm also passionate about giving online tips about golf. Check out my blog to learn more about the game.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Thank you so much for posting the blog with the great tips and content. I've bookmarked this and will definitely share this blog post with Aberdeen Physical Therapy.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Understanding the capacities and breaking down the exhibitions of the groups and the people may even be more imperative and this will enable you to pick where to put your cash. browse this site

    ReplyDelete
  10. Right off the bat, Sports Betting Champ, John Morrison, is a widely acclaimed sports handicapper, and expert card shark. In his 28 years, in the betting scene, he is yet to have a losing season. zcode system discount

    ReplyDelete
  11. In this age of hypocrisy, the writer has written every word with all his soul poured into it.
    UFC 232 fights

    ReplyDelete
  12. You there, this is really good post here. Thanks for taking the time to post such valuable information. Quality content is what always gets the visitors coming. best draw prediction site

    ReplyDelete
  13. Good post related to sport injuries. I have plantar fasciitis and I use only best socks for plantar fasciitis

    ReplyDelete
  14. It’s also very useful to get statements from witnesses or friends and family after the accident, particularly if they’ve helped you recover or get about while you’ve been injured. Know more from nigelaskew-solicitor.co.uk.

    ReplyDelete
  15. I admit, I have not been on this web page in a long time... however it was another joy to see It is such an important topic and ignored by so many, even professionals. I thank you to help making people more aware of possible issues does inversion therapy help sciatica

    ReplyDelete
  16. I think that thanks for the valuabe information and insights you have so provided here. inversion chair reviews

    ReplyDelete
  17. Just arranging and preparing vambos.com along these lines will guarantee quality arrangement for the sports crews to achieve top execution in sports later.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Very nice article. I enjoyed reading your post. very nice share. I want to twit this to my followers. Thanks !.
    Anthony Castro

    ReplyDelete
  19. This creator elaborates that a portion of these standards are: obligation; designation of power and correspondence. Most Dangerous Sports

    ReplyDelete
  20. There are numerous preferences of online football betting, regardless of whether you are a bad-to-the-bone betting fan or a basic easygoing card shark. เว็บไซต์แทงบอลออนไลน์

    ReplyDelete
  21. By making this showing you can win energizing prizes also. In the event that blessed you can win great honors like a sumptuous vehicle or a remote trek.Download matches schedule of Euro T20 Slam

    ReplyDelete
  22. Such a strikingly basic article.I basically wish to offer a creature proceed for the standard data you have perfect here on this post. https://krmlight.com/8-ft-led-bulbs/

    ReplyDelete
  23. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Our credit repair services work to fix past credit mistakes and verify credit report accuracy. Talk to a credit repair expert today!  트레이딩벳 먹튀

    ReplyDelete
  25. On the off chance that by chance the group wins by the quantity of focuses that were picked as the spread, the game is known as a push.
    premier league relegation odds

    ReplyDelete
  26. Should you feel find it difficult to, you undoubtedly is not able to; If you don't intend, to have failing. Things are subject to intellect, reduction of hundreds exercises are hopeless prior to starting. รูเล็ต

    ReplyDelete
  27. Thanks for a marvelous posting! I seriously enjoyed reading it, you happen to be a great author. I will remember to bookmark your blog and will often come back at some point. I want to encourage you to definitely continue your great writing, have a nice day! my blog post
    Euro T20 Slam League Venue Stadiums
    Euro T20 Slam League Predictions Current Matches
    Euro T20 Slam Live Score Ball By Ball

    ReplyDelete
  28. I am thankful to you for sharing this plethora of useful information. I found this resource utmost beneficial for me. Thanks a lot for hard work.
    Euro T20 Slam Broadcasting

    ReplyDelete
  29. Good post. If you are looking for SEO Audit Reporter please check.

    ReplyDelete
  30. This post is really helpful to know. Thank you very much Euro T20 Slam Points Table

    ReplyDelete
  31. This post is really helpful to know. Thank you very much Euro T20 Slam Points Table

    ReplyDelete
  32. This post is very helpful. Thank you for sharing. See european t20 cricket league

    ReplyDelete
  33. สโบเบท เว็บแทงบอลที่ดีที่สุด ที่สามารถให้คุณลุ้นรับเงินรางวัลได้แบบ 24 ชั่วโมง พร้อมทั้งยัง ฝาก-ถอน ได้แบบไม่มีขั้นต่ำ และยังลุ้นรับโปรโมชั่น โบนัสดีๆ ได้ตลอดการเข้าใช้งาน

    ReplyDelete
  34. Mice are insects that cause harm to humans and also many household items. They can feed on anything. They can eat leaves, wood, grains, clothes and many other things. In addition, it can infect humans also serious diseases if they can bite, and therefore must be eliminated permanently, and this is what the company does using the latest scientific methods.

    شركة مكافحة النمل الابيض بالرياض
    شركة مكافحة حشرات بالرياض
    شركة رش مبيدات بالرياض
    افضل شركة مكافحة حشرات

    ReplyDelete
  35. Just pure classic stuff from you here. I have never seen such a brilliantly written article in a long time. I am thankful to you that you produced this! Percussion Therapy

    ReplyDelete
  36. Despite the fact that not really exceptionally reasonable, it is about the look and the explanation that this gives. Embracing a specific one of a kind picture like this enables the gathering to emerge from the remainder of the populace.Bundesliga wetten

    ReplyDelete
  37. Wonderful blog! I found it while surfing around on Yahoo News. Do you have any suggestions on how to get listed in Yahoo News? I’ve been trying for a while but I never seem to get there! Appreciate it. situs judi online

    ReplyDelete
  38. Wonderful blog! I found it while surfing around on Yahoo News. Do you have any suggestions on how to get listed in Yahoo News? I’ve been trying for a while but I never seem to get there! Appreciate it. Physical Therapy allen park

    ReplyDelete
  39. This is a great inspiring article. I am pretty much pleased with your good work. You put really very helpful information. Really insightful and well-written article. Again thanks for your reviews and will definitely be back for some tips and tricks. Such an amazing post !! I am inspired by your work and got some great ideas. It really gives me information that I am looking for. Thanks and keep sharing This is a great inspiring article. I am pretty much pleased with your good work. You put really very helpful information.
    Jashan e Eid Milad un Nabi Wishes
    Eid Milad un Nabi Wishes
    Milad un Nabi Wishes
    Eid Milad un Nabi Wishes Images
    eid milad un nabi wishes in english
    eid milad un nabi wishes in hindi
    eid milad un nabi wishes in arabic
    eid milad un nabi wishes in urdu
    eid milad un nabi mubarak wishes
    eid milad un nabi mubarak wishes Wallpaper

    ReplyDelete
  40. Im planning to get one 2 weeks from now but still not sure if I'm going for the Titanium or Trend.. With the Php2,000 difference in the monthly ammortization, is it really worth getting the Titanium?Pickup basketball


    ReplyDelete
  41. Nice post. I learn something more challenging on different blogs everyday. It will always be stimulating to read content from other writers and practice a little something from their store. I?d prefer to use some with the content on my blog whether you don?t mind. Natually I?ll give you a link on your web blog. Thanks for sharing.
    Appoint Best Orthopedic Surgeons for sports injuries in Lahore and recover your injuries fast.

    ReplyDelete
  42. Perfectly composed content , thankyou for entropy.why not look here

    ReplyDelete
  43. Great post I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this interesting and knowledgeable article. trực tiếp liverpool mu

    ReplyDelete
  44. Many homework on the continual hunt along with offstage on the road to winning. Definitely not attached, simple to-fall as a result of wayside; And not investigation, afterward into a path travel toward the black. 에볼루션카지노

    ReplyDelete
  45. It looks like you have put tremendous effort into finding the facts. I really appreciate your research. Hope to read more articles on your blog. Keep it up.
    stem cells for hair restoration

    ReplyDelete
  46. Great! It sounds good. Thanks for sharing.. w88coid.com

    ReplyDelete
  47. This is my first time visit to your blog and I am very interested in the articles that you serve. Provide enough knowledge for me. Thank you for sharing useful and don't forget, keep sharing useful info: 로투스홀짝

    ReplyDelete

  48. Mice are insects that cause harm to humans and also many household items. They can feed on anything. They can eat leaves, wood, grains, clothes and many other things. In addition, it can infect humans also serious diseases if they can bite, and therefore must be eliminated permanently, and this is what the company does using the latest scientific methods.Bubble Soccer Gold Coast

    ReplyDelete
  49. Rewards are so important for kids. I think these tips are important to recognize that children should evaluate themselves and reflect on their actions. Thanks for sharing this!play soccer in your browser

    ReplyDelete

  50. Mice are insects that cause harm to humans and also many household items. They can feed on anything. They can eat leaves, wood, grains, clothes and many other things. In addition, it can infect humans also serious diseases if they can bite, and therefore must be eliminated permanently, and this is what the company does using the latest scientific methods.Sports results

    ReplyDelete
  51. I am always searching online for articles that can help me. There is obviously a lot to know about this. I think you made some good points in Features also. Keep working, great job! 서포터먹튀

    ReplyDelete
  52. Rewards are so important for kids. I think these tips are important to recognize that children should evaluate themselves and reflect on their actions. Thanks for sharing this!roblox codes list

    ReplyDelete
  53. Interestingly you write, I will address you'll find exciting and interesting things on similar topics. dedicated server in germany

    ReplyDelete